3D printing to replace all types of manufacturing

I recently came across a interesting question in Quora, and I decided to assemble my thoughts in a blog post. So here’s what I think…

Breaking down the question

Let’s break down this complicated question. To be adopted in manufacturing, 3D printing has to compete with technologies such as:

  • CNC machining, Sheet metal fabrication, and Die Casting and Metal Injection Molding (on the metal side)
  • Injection molding, vacuum casting, thermoforming and laser cutting (on the plastic side)

For greater industrial adoption, 3D printing has to beat these technologies in terms of overall manufacturing cost and/or part performance.

Let’s pause for a moment…

Why does 3D printing have to compete with these established technologies? Why can’t it be used in parallel?

Imagine this scenario: you are an engineer working on an exciting new piece of hardware (let’s say Tesla’s Model 4). You have the option to manufacture parts of the subsystem you’re designing using one of three different technologies: 3D printing, CNC machining and Die casting.

How will you convince your manager that 3D printing is the way to go? How does it add value to the final product? Is it stronger, lighter, stiffer? What about cheaper? Why should we make the change?

The uphill battle for any new technology isn’t just that has to be better than an existing process; it has to be MUCH better.

In my mind, this is how 3D printing competes with other manufacturing technologies. The technology and materials are (slowly getting) there. It is a societal change that needs to happen now, and this takes time.

Back to answering the question…

To fully understand why this is possible, we should consider how 3D printing fulfills the needs of three distinct groups:

  1. Design engineers
  2. Manufacturing/Supply Chain engineers
  3. Professional end users & consumers

Design engineers

Design engineers are attracted to 3D printing for two reasons: its design freedom and its manufacturing speed.

They can take advantage of the design freedom that the technology offers to create parts that are optimized for their function. For example, they can use advanced CAD techniques like topology optimization to develop lightweight structures and significantly improve the efficiency of their designs.

Design engineers also love the speed of 3D printing. In fact, the most established use of 3D printing today is prototyping. 3D printing has captured almost the entire prototyping market for plastics and is rapidly expanding on the metal side.

Note that until recently that was not possible for a simple reason: the materials were different than what design engineers were used to. Certification and standardization are a must in many industries.

Manufacturing & Supply Chain engineers

Manufacturing & Supply Chain engineers are most interested in the on-demand nature of 3D printing.

The key question here is: “how can I reduce the overall production costs of my organization?” 3D printing is an ideal solution for applications in spare part production, for instance. Parts can be stored in the “digital inventory” until they are required and then manufactured-on-demand and close to the location of use. This can minimize the overhead costs and transportation costs, improving the efficiency of the supply chain.

Manufacturing where you need it & when you need it; this one of the greatest appeals of 3D printing.

Don’t forget that manufacturing with 3D printing involves only a few manufacturing steps. Some post-processing will always be required (e.g. sintering, support removal, surface smoothing etc.), but overall the process is much simpler. 20 distinct operations can turn into 4 (for instance, see this application from Milwaukee Tools )

End users & consumers

End users & consumers have already started enjoying the benefits of 3D printed products without even knowing it (most of the times). For consumers, the main benefit is mass customization.

One of the earliest commercially successful applications of 3D printing came from hearing aids. In fact, the companies that did not adopt the technology, very fast when out of business, as they could not keep up with the competition.

Another very nice example came last year from Gillette and their 3D printed razor handles. We will see more applications like this in the years to come.

How would you answer this question? Send me a message or leave me a comment below and let’s start a discussion.

P.S. I recently finished working on a report on the current state of the 3D printing industry. If you want to learn more on this topic, keep an eye out for the release of the 3D Hubs 3D Printing Trends 2019. The report will be available for download here:Trends | 3D Hubs


My partner and I approached David at Re3dtech with our project and were greeted with kind and caring service. Throughout the last couple of months we have placed several orders in varying size and were even able to sit down with David and the owner to discuss our needs as a small business. Through this sit down we saw their passion for assisting both small and large clients in achieving their goals. We even had a hiccup with a batch of prints that was immediately addressed and remedied with precision and care. I almost don't want to recommend these guys because I feel like I have stumbled upon a hidden gem in 3D printing services and selfishly want to keep it to myself. Jokes aside we will be continuing our business relationship with the folks there and look forward to growing our order quantities and business with their help.
Re3DTech was instrumental in helping us get our product, Stroba™, to market faster! We needed a technology that could do snap fits and looks and feels as close the injection molded part as possible, and Re3D Tech was there for us. We used SOLIDWORKS Make to get in touch originally, upload models directly, and sign an NDA directly with their excellent team. It was really simple and easy to use their quoting tool as well. Excellent prices, excellent lead times, and superior quality are perfect words to describe our experience with Re3DTech. We went through many prototypes for Stroba™, and we at Goodfriend Innovations™ use Re3DTech for our other rapid prototyping jobs to help get our additional productions out to market faster than the competition. 5 Stars
I provided RE3DTECH three laser scanned ".stl" files for 3-D printing of prototypes. I used their on-line quote and file delivery process. The file acceptance and resultant quote were returned quickly. The parts were received at the quoted time. The parts are quite complex with many holes, angles, curvatures and notches. Each of the parts came out identical to the scanned parts dimensionally and passed the form/fit/function test in the upper level assembly. RE3DTECH has a high quality business process and produces high quality products. I will use them for future prototyping projects and recommend RE3DTECH.
Re3dtech is one of the most honest and reputable companies we have done business with. We decided to look into options for getting parts made in the USA for the retail market. It was awesome to find a local company with humble staff looking to provide their services meeting our criteria, not to mention meeting the Re3tech crew face to face and checking out their operation. Peter was very honest, knowledgable about design. Peter's creative element made working with him a great pleasure. Jim's flexibility was a breath of fresh air and greatly appreciated. CentralSound is proud to scratch the surface with Made in the USA parts in the retail market now, thanks to Re3dtech. Hope to do more business with them in the future.
Re3dtech has consistently delivered the best service I have ever received in the industry. Their response time is unmatched and they always stand by their parts and quality. They regularly make me look like an all star at my job.
It is always a pleasure to have a vendor that provides quality, experience, and always shows as much care for your order, and your product as you do!